Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Judge James W. Haley Jr.

Feb 15, 2019

Conviction affirmed despite counsel’s suspension

The court affirmed a man’s conviction for distribution of Oxycodone and rejected his claim of ineffective assistance of counsel, finding that although his attorney was twice temporarily suspended while his case was pending, he was afforded licensed counsel at every stage of the proceeding, and he chose to proceed with her in spite of the […]

Jan 28, 2019

Conviction affirmed despite counsel’s suspension

The court affirmed a man’s conviction for distribution of Oxycodone and rejected his claim of ineffective assistance of counsel, finding that although his attorney was twice temporarily suspended while his case was pending, he was afforded licensed counsel at every stage of the proceeding, and he chose to proceed with her in spite of the […]

Jan 12, 2019

Man’s move out of state with girlfriend was desertion

Where a husband purchased a home in Washington state with his former high-school girlfriend in March 2016, which was several months before he left the marital residence in July 2016, the circuit court did not abuse its discretion in granting wife a divorce based on desertion. Background The parties married in 1975. In 1991, they […]

Jan 12, 2019

Right to challenge sentence waived by failure to object

Because the defendant’s attorney did not affirmatively object when the trial court imposed on his client a provision of no contact with the victim, the defendant waived this argument for appeal. Background Viewed in the light most favorable to the commonwealth, the evidence established that the victim had met appellant at work and had been […]

Jan 9, 2018

Based on Burglar’s Intent, Screwdriver is a Deadly Weapon

Although a screwdriver is not a per se deadly weapon, the court of appeals held that, for purposes of applying an enhanced statutory penalty, it may be defined as a deadly weapon based on its possessor’s intent and subsequent use. The Defendant, Choon Poong Lee, was convicted of statutory burglary in violation of Code § 18.2-91 and, […]

Dec 18, 2017

Evidence – Medically Necessary

Pacheco v. J.P. Masonry Inc. (VLW No. 017-7-287, 7 pp.) (Haley, J.) Appealed from Va. Workers’ Compensation Comm., Va. App. Unpub. Holding:  Claimant-worker, injured in a work-related accident that resulted in a below-the-knee amputation of his left foot, challenged the finding by the full commission that his requested “running blade” was not medically necessary and […]

May 10, 2017

Perjury Conviction Upheld for Criminal Complaint

The Court of Appeals affirms defendant’s conviction for perjury based on his having filed a sworn criminal complaint outlining a prison guard’s alleged assault while closing the tray slot door on defendant’s arm when serving him a meal, these statements would have caused the magistrate to issue a warrant, if believed, and the jury reasonably […]

May 3, 2017

Light-Duty Employee Needed to Seek Work

The commission did not err in holding that claimant did not sufficiently market his residual capacity for work during his light-duty status with United Parcel Service after knee-replacement surgery, the Court of Appeals holds. The record establishes that claimant’s doctor had placed him on light-duty status and had prescribed only “Advil” instead of the narcotic […]

Jan 25, 2017

Cell Phone Texts Had No Foundation

The commonwealth did not show a cell phone found in the vehicle defendant was driving belonged to him and the trial court erred in admitting text messages about marijuana sales; the Court of Appeals reverses defendant’s drug distribution conviction. This court has previously held that text messages constitute writings for purposes of the best evidence […]

Nov 29, 2016

No Prejudice from Denial of Teeth Removal

At defendant’s trial for attacking and sexually assaulting one woman and attacking a second woman and steal­ing her car, in the same afternoon, the trial court did not err reversibly in re­fusing to allow defendant to remove his gold teeth before the jury, in an effort to prove that he was not the assailant because […]

Nov 16, 2016

Prior Conviction Shown for Third-Offense Larceny

A defendant charged with larceny for removing clothing from hangers at a Kohls store and taking it to the return desk for store credit can be convicted of larceny, third offense, under Va. Code §§ 18.2-96 and 18.2-104; the trial court did not err in rejecting defendant’s motion in limine arguing that she could not […]

Oct 17, 2016

Passenger Tagged for Baggie Thrown from Window

Although appellant testified he did not know there was marijuana in the car in which he was a passenger, and from which someone threw a bag of marijuana packaged for distribution from the pas­senger-side window, the Court of Appeals affirms the trial court decision rejecting appellant’s credibility, and affirms his con­viction for possession of marijuana […]

Verdicts & Settlements

See All Verdicts & Settlements

Opinion Digests

See All Digests