Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Judge Robert G. Doumar

Aug 15, 2016

Child Porn ‘Playpen’ Warrant Approved

Following its earlier opinion covering the same Fourth Amendment issues, a Norfolk U.S. District Court upholds the government’s use of a Network Investi­gative Technique to conduct searches of personal computers after its seizure of “Playpen,” a website that facilitates dis­tribution of child pornography, and de­nies two motions to suppress evidence obtained by the government after [&hell[...]

Jul 25, 2016

No Patent for Computer Claim’s ‘Abstract Idea’

Plaintiffs’ claims that defendant’s ‘432 patent, relating to a method for centralized identification and authen­tication of users and their transactions to increase security in e-commerce, are invalid because they are directed to an abstract idea and thus are ineligible for patent protection under 35 U.S.C. § 101; the Norfolk U.S. District Court dismisses plaintiffs’ claims. […]

Jun 20, 2016

Court Upholds Child Porn ‘Playpen’ Warrant

A Norfolk U.S. District Court says the government’s use of a Network Inves­tigative Technique to conduct searches of personal computers after its seizure of “Playpen,” a website that facilitates distribution of child pornography, is a search under the Fourth Amendment, but the court denies two motions to sup­press evidence obtained by the govern­ment after a […]

Jun 20, 2016

Delivery Failure Breaches Medical Supply Contract

In this contract dispute between plaintiff BMK Solutions LLC, a Virgin­ia producer of medical kits certified as a Tactical Combat Casualty Care govern­ment contractor, and defendant BioStat LLC, a Florida LLC and distributor of Medtrade gauze and bandage products made by a British manufacturer, a Nor­folk U.S. District Court says BioStat breached a contract for […]

May 30, 2016

No Benefits for Navy Seal Suicide’s Family

The widow of a man who retired after serv­ing 17 years as a Navy Seal, and who showed signs of chronic traumatic encephalopathy from exposure to enemy gunfire and mortar fire blasts, cannot collect $500,000 in sup­plemental life insurance benefits after her husband died of a self-inflicted gunshot; the Norfolk U.S. District Court says the […]

May 23, 2016

Employer ID Did Not Create ‘Covered Auto’

Although a truck-tractor involved in an accident with a bicyclist had the US­DOT Carrier ID number of the driver’s employer, the vehicle was not a “covered auto” under the employer’s commercial automotive policy and the employer’s in­surance carrier also is not liable for the bicyclist’s injuries under an MCS-90 en­dorsement to the policy; the Norfolk […]

May 16, 2016

Employer ID Did Not Create ‘Covered Auto’

Although a truck-tractor involved in an accident with a bicyclist had the US­DOT Carrier ID number of the driver’s employer, the vehicle was not a “covered auto” under the employer’s commercial automotive policy and the employer’s in­surance carrier also is not liable for the bicyclist’s injuries under an MCS-90 en­dorsement to the policy; the Norfolk […]

Apr 4, 2016

Welcome Center Materials Are ‘Protected Speech’

A publisher of visitors’ guides to Vir­ginia does not have standing to chal­lenge Virginia Department of Trans­portation policies governing what may be displayed in VDOT Welcome Centers and rest areas; although the publisher has standing to challenge the fees for placing materials in the Welcome Cen­ters, the Welcome Center displays are government speech exempt from […]

Mar 27, 2016

Mold case was to be heard in Norfolk

A contentious lawsuit over mold in military housing is set to go to trial Tuesday in Norfolk federal court. Pre-trial skirmishes continued in recent days, with U.S. District Judge Raymond Jackson blocking one defense witness. Jackson termed the lengthy case “overlitigated” and “overcomplicated.” The case has been marked by an early fight over e-discovery and […]

Mar 14, 2016

Arbitration Ordered for Shipping Contract

In this dispute over plaintiff coal company’s suit for damages to a shipment of mining shovels from Australia to Hampton Roads, the Norfolk U.S. District Court construes the chartered vessel’s motion to dismiss as a motion to compel arbitration, which the court grants. Plaintiff Southern Coal Corporation, through its agent AAMAC, contracted with defendant IEG […]

Mar 7, 2016

Federal Claims Dismissed, State Claims Remanded

In plaintiff’s lawsuit alleging defendant police officers were grossly negligent in failing to obtain prompt medical assistance and delaying in order to conduct sobriety tests after plaintiff was injured in a one-vehicle accident, the Norfolk U.S. District Court says plaintiff has failed to state any federal claims, and his suit is remanded back to state […]

Mar 7, 2016

No Coverage for False Advertising Claim

In a declaratory judgment action seeking coverage under a commercial liability policy for defendant Crawl Space Door System’s defense of a New Jersey lawsuit, the Norfolk U.S. District Court says the “failure to conform” and  “intellectual property” policy exclusions bar coverage in this lawsuit filed by a competitor who has sued defendant for false advertising, […]

Verdicts & Settlements

See All Verdicts & Settlements

Opinion Digests

See All Digests