Man left with permanent shoulder injury after auto accident — $125,000 verdict

Type of action: Personal injury

Injuries alleged: Permanent shoulder subluxation without definite labrum tear, burns from airbag being deployed and whiplash

Name of case: Coffman v. Tran

Court: Frederick County Circuit Court

Case no.: CL20000418-00

Tried before: Jury

Name of judge or mediator: Judge William W. Eldridge IV

Date resolved: 7/15/2021

Special damages: $15,846.26 in medical; $2,424.46 in lost wages

Demand: $150,000

Offer: $30,000

Verdict or settlement: Verdict

Amount: $125,000

Attorney for plaintiff (and city): Amy L. Bradley, Tysons

Insurance carrier: Allstate

Description of case: The 54-year-old male plaintiff had a physically demanding job, including everything from cleaning to unloading shipments. A hard impact car accident in November 2018 left him with permanent shoulder subluxation but no definite labrum tear. When the airbags exploded, he clenched down on a piece of hard candy, breaking his dentures.

Plaintiff underwent conservative treatment including hospital, orthopedist, one cortisone injection and two short rounds of physical therapy. None of plaintiff’s treatment provided any long-term relief. Dr. Bruno provided medical examination and de bene esse deposition regarding nature of injury including permanency.

Plaintiff’s evidence included testimony from lay witnesses who testified that he is unable to complete some of his job duties without help and inability to hunt and fish as he could prior to the accident.

[021-T-105]