Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Judge Rebecca Beach Smith

Aug 25, 2025

Constitutional: Indian Nation’s lawsuit over Medicaid reimbursements is dismissed

Where the Nansemond Indian Nation sued the Commonwealth of Virginia and state officials over Medicaid reimbursements, but each of the claims failed as a matter of law, the lawsuit was dismissed.

Jun 1, 2025

Tort: DTSA lawsuit is dismissed

Where one mortgage company sued another mortgage company, alleging it violated the Defend Trade Secrets Act after it hired the plaintiff’s employee, but the complaint and attachments did not plausibly show misappropriation of trade secrets, this claim was dismissed.

Jan 2, 2025

Jurisdiction: Man alleges AI company failed to grant him 10 percent equity interest

Where a Virginia resident alleged a leading AI company failed to grant him a 10 percent equity interest as compensation for his employment, but the company was not subject to […]

Oct 7, 2024

Employment: Quid pro quo sexual harassment claim dismissed

Where a woman sued her former employer for quid pro quo sexual harassment, but she failed to plead facts showing the alleged harassers held any type of supervisory authority over […]

Aug 19, 2024

Administrative: Social Security Administration prevails in benefits dispute

Where substantial evidence supported the administrative law judge’s decision denying a woman’s application for Social Security Disability Insurance Benefits and Supplemental Security Income, it was affirmed. Background Plaintiff’s complaint appeals […]

Apr 22, 2024

Contract: Court defers ruling on restrictive covenant

Where a company sued for violating a restrictive covenant in a purchase agreement argued the covenant was overbroad and thus unenforceable, the court deferred ruling on the motion to dismiss. […]

Apr 8, 2024

Sanctions: Court vacates default order against Coast Guard officer

Where an entry of default was entered against a Coast Guard officer after she failed to respond to a suit by her former live-in nanny, but the officer (mistakenly) believed […]

Jan 9, 2024

No wrongful death negligence claim against subcontractor

Where a complaint failed to plead facts supporting a negligence claim arising out of a woman’s wrongful death, and the woman’s estate failed to identify additional facts that would allow […]

Dec 11, 2023

Court again refuses to reduce defendant’s sentence

Where the court previously twice reduced the sentence of a man found guilty of 15 counts of drug, firearm and witness tampering offenses from 1,020 months’ imprisonment to 415 months’ […]

Nov 27, 2023

Former employee’s claims survive motion to dismiss

Where a former employee alleged facts plausibly suggesting that she was subjected to a hostile work environment, retaliated against after she complained about the conduct and that a reasonable person […]

Nov 14, 2023

Pro se False Claims Act complaint dismissed

Where a pro se plaintiff purported to file a complaint under the False Claims Act, but the allegations were about a dispute with her neighbor, a plaintiff cannot proceed with […]

Nov 6, 2023

$70M settlement approved in antitrust suit

Where a settlement of an antitrust suit was fair, reasonable and adequate, it was approved and the plaintiffs’ attorneys were awarded more than $23.3 million. Background The End Payor Plaintiffs, […]

Verdicts & Settlements

See All Verdicts & Settlements

Opinion Digests

See All Digests